الذنوب والمعاصي تضر ولابد، فإن مما اتفق عليه العلماء وأرباب السلوك أن للمعاصي آثارا وثارات، وأن لها عقوبات على قلب العاصي وبدنه، وعلى دينه وعقله، وعلى دنياه وآخرته.

اختيار هذا الخط


الذنوب والمعاصي تضر ولابد، فإن مما اتفق عليه العلماء وأرباب السلوك أن للمعاصي آثارا وثارات، وأن لها عقوبات على قلب العاصي وبدنه، وعلى دينه وعقله، وعلى دنياه وآخرته.

اختيار هذا الخط

Two fabricated Hadeeths prohibiting high buildings

  • 286

    Question

    In At-Targheeb wat-Tarheeb, I read the following Hadeeths (narrations):
    1- When a man raises his building above seven Thiraa‘s (64 cm), he will be called, "O the most wicked man! Where are you going?"
    2- When Allaah The Almighty wants to disgrace a man, He lets him spend his money on buildings.
    How authentic are these Hadeeths especially at this time of skyscrapers?

    Answer

    All perfect praise be to Allaah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allaah, and that Muhammad, , is His Slave and Messenger.

     

    In At-Targheeb wat-Tarheeb, Imaam Al-Munthiri, , said about the first Hadeeth that it is not authentic. It was narrated by Ibn Abi Ad-Dunya on the authority of ‘Ammaar ibn ‘Aamir who is a Taabi‘i (Follower). So, the Hadeeth is a Mursal Hadeeth and cannot be attributed to the Prophet, .

    The second Hadeeth was narrated by At-Tabaraani, , in Al-Awsat and Al-Bayhaqi, , in Shu‘ab Al-'Eemaan, but As-Suyooti, Al-Munaawi, and Al-Albaani, , classified it as Dha‘eef (weak).

    The two Hadeeths are not authentic. However, scholars stated that building is dispraised when it is done for any purpose other than purposes of the Sharee‘ah (Islamic law), that leads to abandoning an obligation or doing a forbidden act, or exceeds one’s need. This is because the worldly life is not an eternal abode.

    Allaah Knows best.

    Related Material

    Fatwas

    Search Fatwa

    You can search for fatwa through many choices



     
     
     

    Most View