Question
As regards raising hands with every Takbeer in Eid prayer, I read from "the book of fasting" of Mohd. Iqbal Kailani the following Hadith: "Waael bin Hujr(R.A) relates that he saw the Messenger of Allah SAWS raising his hands with ever Takbir" (Transmitted by Ahmed).In the above Hadith it is not clear whether Wail bin Hujr(R.A.) saw Prophet Mohammad SAWS raising his hands during Eid prayer or during daily prayers.Shaykh Al-albanee (RT) said in Tamammul Minnah that the Hadith narrated by Umar (R.A) transmitted by al-Baihaqi is weak in chain of narration and he hadn't come across any report from son of Umar (R.A) {Ibn Umar(R.A) } and therefore he came to conclusion that raising of hands in Eid prayer is not Sunnah.If the above Hadith transmitted by Ahmed of Wail bin Hujr(R.A) is authentic and that too Wail bin Hujr(R.A) saw prophet Mohammad SAWS raising his hands in Eid prayer than it can be followed, otherwise the opinion of Shaykh al-Albanee stands most correct.Now my question is the Hadith transmitted by Ahmed of Wail bin Hujr(R.A) is authentic ? Does Wail bin Hujr(R.A) saw prophet Mohammad SAWS raising his hands in Eid prayer as quoted in this Hadith?


Search Fatwa 

