Authenticity of additional part in hadeeth
Fatwa No: 359023

  • Fatwa Date:18-9-2017 - Thul-Hijjah 27, 1438
  • Rating:

Question

I have a question on hadith grades. If a hadith from a primary source of Hadith appears in another book with a different wording, and the author gives the hadith a particular grade, does this grade apply to the words found in the primary source as well? For example, this hadith from Musnad Ahmad (primary source): Abu Hurayrah, may Allah be pleased with him, narrated that the Messenger of Allah, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, said, "The people of Paradise will enter Paradise without body hear; beardless; white in complexion; with curly hair; aged thirty-three; and in the form of Adam, peace be upon him, sixty feet tall and seven feet wide. (Musnad Ahmed - 7933)
I read in Ilal Al-Hadith that Ibn Abi Haatim declared the hadith to be authentic, with the same chain of narrators as is found in Musnad Ahmad, but the wording is different (i.e, it makes no mention of seven feet wide or curly hair). I was wondering, is the part about seven feet wide and curly hair considered authentic to Ibn Abi Haatim Ar-Raazi with the rest of the hadith due to this?

Answer

All perfect praise be to Allah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam, is His slave and Messenger.

The authenticity of this addition to Ibn Abi Haatim in the mentioned example cannot be decisively stated. It is known that there are five conditions for a particular hadeeth to be classified as authentic. Three of these conditions are related to the chain of narrators, and two are related to the text.

The three conditions related to the chain of narrators are the following:

1) Connectedness (i.e. every narrator must have met his predecessor, who narrated it to him in an uninterrupted chain all the way back to the Prophet, sallallaahu ‘alayhi wa sallam).

2) Trustworthiness.

3) Precision of memorization.

The two conditions related to the text are the following:

4) The absence of Shuthooth (which means that the hadeeth is narrated by a trustworthy narrator but differs from the narration of other trustworthy narrators) in the text .

5) The absence of ʻIllah (subtle hidden defects identified by versed Hadeeth scholars and critics, deeming the hadeeth inauthentic while on the surface it may seem authentic) in the text.

Hence, if the Hadeeth scholar does not declare a particular part in a hadeeth authentic, it is possible that it may be classified as an aspect of Shuthooth or ʻIllah in that hadeeth according to his opinion, even if he declares the chain of narrators of a part of the hadeeth authentic or classified this same chain of narrators in other ahaadeeth as authentic.

Ibn Al-Qayyim  may  Allaah  have  mercy  upon  him wrote, "It is known that the authenticity of the chain of narrators is one of the conditions of the authenticity of a hadeeth, but it is not the only condition. A hadeeth is declared authentic when a set of conditions are met, including the following: an authentic chain of narrators, absence of ʻIllah, absence of Shuthooth and Nakaarah (which means that a narration reported by a weak narrator goes against another authentic hadeeth)."

Allah knows best.

Related Fatwa