Fatwa No : 362626
Refuting the false claim that Mu‘aawiyah drank alcohol
Fatwa Date : Safar 4, 1439 / 24-10-2017
Some Shias present the following hadith to prove that Mu‘aawiyyah, may Allah be pleased with him, drank alcohol. ‘Abdullaah ibn Buraidah said, “I entered upon Mu‘aawiyyah with my father, then he (Mu‘aawiyyah) made us sit on a mattress, then he brought food to us and we ate, then he brought drink to us, Mu‘aawiyyah drank, and then he offered that to my father, thus (my father) said, ‘I never drank it since the Messenger of Allah, sallallahu ʻalayhi wa sallam, made it haram’...” [Musnad Ahmad bin Hanbal, Volume 5, page 347, Hadith: 22991] I want to know more about this hadith. May Allah reward you.
All perfect praise be to Allah, the Lord of the worlds. I testify that there is none worthy of worship except Allah and that Muhammad, sallallaahu &699;alayhi wa sallam, is His slave and Messenger.
The mentioned hadeeth does not indicate that Mu&699;aawiyah drank alcohol. Allah forbids that he does! Had he drunk it, Buraydah would not have sat at a table where alcohol is drunk, and he would have left the place.
The hadeeth was cited by Imaam Ahmad in his Musnad as follows:
“Zayd ibn Al-Hubaab narrated from Husayn that &699;Abdullah ibn Buraydah said, ‘My father and I entered upon Mu&699;aawiyah, so he made us sit on a mattress; then we were brought food and we ate, then we were brought a drink, and Mu&699;aawiyah drank and then offered the drink to my father. Then he (meaning Mu&699;awiyah) said, 'I never drank it since the Messenger of Allah, sallallaahu &699;alayhi wa sallam, prohibited it.' Mu&699;awiyah then said, 'I was the most handsome young man in Quraysh with good front teeth. And there is nothing which I find as enjoyable as I used to find it when I was young except milk or a person with whom I have a good conversation.'’”
Shu&699;ayb Al-Arnaa’oot said:
“Its chain of narration is strong. Husayn was nicknamed Ibn Waaqid Al-Marwazi, and his narrations were cited by Abu Daawood, An-Nasaa’i, At-Tirmithi, and Ibn Maajah. His narrations in Saheeh Muslim are cited as supportive evidence to other narrations with the same chain of narration, and his narrations in Saheeh Al-Bukhaari are reported as a Mu’allaq hadeeth, i.e. a hadeeth whose whole chain of narrators is omitted. He was a sadooq reporter (an honest reporter who may make mistakes). The rest of the narrators of this hadeeth are trustworthy who are cited in Saheeh (sound) Hadeeth books ... The statement, ‘And I have not drunk it since the Messenger of Allah, sallallaahu &699;alayhi wa sallam, prohibited it’ was said by Mu&699;aawiyah ibn Abi Sufyaan, and perhaps he said so when he saw disapproval in Buraydah's face for (mistakenly) thinking that it was a prohibited drink.”
This makes it clear that the one who said 'I never drank it since the Messenger of Allah, sallallaahu &699;alayhi wa sallam, prohibited it.' was Mu&699;aawiyah, and not Buraydah, in order to dispel what Buraydah might think that this drink was alcohol. So Mu’aawiyah said that he never had it (alcohol) since its prohibition was revealed; rather, he mentioned that he enjoyed milk just as he used to enjoy it when he was a young man in Makkah (i.e. what he actually drank was milk and not alcohol).
Even assuming that it was Buraydah who made that statement, then it is possible that what Mu‘aawiyah was drinking was Nabeeth (water in which dates or grapes or other fruit was soaked) that did not intoxicate; i.e. was not fermented to the extent of causing intoxication. Buraydah chose not to drink it to avoid a doubtful matter. Many scholars held that it is permissible to drink Nabeeth provided that it did not reach the extent of causing intoxication. An-Nawawi said about Nabeeth, “The view of our school as well as that of the majority of the scholars is that it is permissible to drink it unless it has become intoxicating, even if it was left soaking for more than three days (and has begun to ferment, which is the start of the alcohol brewing process).”
He added, “Our evidence is the hadeeth of Buraydah in which the Messenger of Allah, sallallaahu &699;alayhi wa sallam, said, ‘I had forbidden you from making Nabeeth except in a waterskin. But now you may make it in all vessels, but do not drink an intoxicant.’ [Muslim] This report is of a general indication and includes the Nabeeth that was left soaking for more than three days. There was no reported forbiddance about the Nabeeth that was left soaking for more than three days. Accordingly, this entails deeming it allowable as long as it has not become intoxicating.”
Allah knows best.